If you’ve been following the NFL, the conversation about Philip Rivers‘ legacy and his rightful place in the Hall of Fame is not new to you. In this article, we delve deep into this debate, analyzing the formidable career of Rivers and why he deserves a spot among the immortals of football.
Setting the Stage
Philip Rivers, a name synonymous with the San Diego Chargers, and later the Indianapolis Colts, has amazed us with some spectacular football. A career filled with highs and lows, it’s time we revisit his journey and evaluate his Hall of Fame credentials.
The Final Throw
Remember the 2020 season NFL playoffs? The Colts faced the Buffalo Bills in the Wild Card Round, a game that ended their season. The game’s final play saw Rivers’ last throw being intercepted, a moment that encapsulates his career – tantalizingly close, yet falling short.
Time for Reflection
On January 20th, 2021, Rivers announced his retirement, igniting the countdown to his Hall of Fame eligibility. The consensus among NFL pundits is that Rivers might have to wait beyond the mandatory five-year period to don the coveted gold jacket.
The Case for Philip Rivers
Does Philip Rivers belong in the Hall of Fame? We believe he does. Let’s walk through the reasons.
The Statistical Prowess
Rivers’ statistical achievements are impressive, to say the least. He ranks fifth among quarterbacks for all-time passing yards (63,440), trailing only Drew Brees, Tom Brady, Brett Favre, and Peyton Manning. Each of these quarterbacks is either in the Hall of Fame or will be, without question.
The Manning Comparison
A common comparison is drawn between Rivers and Eli Manning, the former New York Giants quarterback who also retired in 2020. Despite Manning’s two Super Bowl titles, Rivers consistently outperformed him season by season.
Rivers had 6,000 more passing yards, 55 more passing touchdowns, and 35 fewer interceptions than Manning. This, despite only an eight-game disparity in career games played (Rivers eight more), indicates a significant performance gap.
Lack of Elite Accolades
One criticism against Rivers’ Hall of Fame inclusion is his lack of elite accolades. No quarterback in the Hall of Fame lacks a Super Bowl Win, League MVP Award or Offensive Player of the Year, or First-Team All-Pro recognition – all of which Rivers does not have. However, his consistent performance should not be overlooked.
Toughness and Tenacity
Rivers was renowned for his competitive edge, toughness, and unique personality. He was known for playing through pain, even in critical games like the 2007 AFC Championship against the New England Patriots where he played with a torn Anterior Cruciate Ligament.
Brief Stint as the Best
From 2008 to 2010, Rivers was arguably the best quarterback in the league. His quarterback rating was above 100.00 each season, showcasing a level of consistency that outshone Brady and Manning during this period.
Late-Career Resurgence
Rivers’ late-career resurgence further strengthens his Hall of Fame argument. Two playoff trips in 2018 and 2020 saw Rivers playing some of his best football well into his thirties.
Philip Rivers: By the Numbers
- Eight Pro-Bowls.
- Fifth All-Time in career passing yards.
- Sixth All-Time in career quarterback rating.
He also led the league at least once in his career in season passing yards (2010), passing touchdowns (2008), passer rating (2008), and completion percentage (2013).
The Final Verdict
While his lack of individual accolades might be a stumbling block, Rivers’ sustained excellence and his ability to make his teams better should be recognized. His inclusion in the Hall of Fame would not only be a testament to his impressive career but also a nod to the gritty, competitive spirit that he brought to the game.
